Discover the Best U.S. Island Getaways for a Fall Escape
If you’re dreaming of a fall vacation, there’s no need to leave the country. The United States is home to some incredible island destinations that offer everything from tropical beaches to cozy autumn getaways. These offshore spots provide a perfect mix of natural beauty, seasonal activities, and affordable travel options. Whether you’re looking for adventure or relaxation, these islands have something special to offer.
Maui, Hawaii: A Slice of Paradise in Autumn
Maui, the second-largest island in Hawaii, is a top choice for those seeking an endless summer feel during the fall. With temperatures ranging from 70 to 80 degrees Fahrenheit and low humidity, it’s the ideal time to enjoy the island’s pristine waters. The ocean remains warm at around 80 degrees, with excellent visibility for snorkeling, diving, and swimming alongside marine life like green sea turtles and manta rays.
Fall is also a great time to explore Maui’s natural wonders, such as the Olowalu reef and Molokini Back Wall. Shoulder season means fewer crowds and lower prices, making it easier to book accommodations and experiences. Plus, the island comes alive with fall festivals like the Festivals of Aloha and the Maui Ukulele Festival.
Nantucket, Massachusetts: A Cozy New England Escape
Nantucket, located 30 miles off the coast of Massachusetts, is a favorite among Redditors for its charming autumn scenery. With daytime temperatures around 65 degrees Fahrenheit and less tourism, it’s the perfect spot for a refined fall getaway. The island’s historic cobblestone streets, lighthouses, and museums make it a must-visit for those seeking a taste of New England Americana.
Autumn brings the scallop season to Nantucket, along with events like the Nantucket Restaurant Week and the Halloween Parade. The beaches are still beautiful, especially at sunset, with stunning views of Great Point Lighthouse and Madaket Beach. Don’t miss out on the pumpkin patch at Bartlett’s Farm.
Catalina Island, California: Coastal Charm and Outdoor Adventures
Catalina Island, just 22 miles off the coast of Long Beach, offers a laid-back escape with amazing weather and fewer crowds in the fall. Days range from mid-60s to over 70 degrees, making it ideal for outdoor activities like hiking, kayaking, and boating. The island’s rugged mountain beauty and wild bison add to its charm.
Avalon, the only incorporated city on the island, features a scenic bay, boutique shops, and the iconic Catalina Casino. Two Harbors, the rustic town on the west side, is perfect for camping and picnicking. Fall also brings festivals like the JazzTrax Festival and the Catalina Film Festival, offering something for every traveler.
Hilton Head, South Carolina: An Upscale Autumn Getaway
Hilton Head Island is a luxurious destination on the East Coast, known for its pristine beaches, golf courses, and upscale resorts. With daytime temperatures in the 80s, it’s the perfect time to enjoy the water and explore the island’s natural beauty. Fall is also a great time to visit due to lower prices and fewer tourists.
The island offers free and affordable activities like nature walks, biking, and beach visits. The Sea Pines Forest Preserve is a great spot for hiking and birdwatching. Fall events include the Crescendo arts festival and the Hilton Head Oyster Festival, adding to the island’s charm.
San Juan Islands, Washington: A Wildlife Wonderland
Located 90 miles off the coast of Seattle, the San Juan Islands are a breathtaking archipelago known for their natural beauty and wildlife. Orcas Island and San Juan Island are the most popular spots, offering stunning views and outdoor adventures. September and October are ideal months to visit, with comfortable temperatures and fewer crowds.
Whale watching is a highlight, with Orca whales being a common sight. The Lime Kiln Point State Park is a great place to observe wildlife and learn about the local ecosystem. Orcas Island also boasts scenic hikes, fine dining, and luxurious accommodations.
How We Chose These Islands
To compile this list, we analyzed Reddit comments from travelers and locals, giving more weight to local voices. We also considered reports from major publications and selected destinations based on factors like favorable weather, seasonal activities, and shoulder season value. Each island was chosen for its unique appeal and affordability during the fall.
Ready to discover more hidden gems and expert travel tips? Subscribe to our free newsletter for access to the world’s best-kept travel secrets.
